For a long time, the language of education has revolved around the message of ‘could do better.’ Whether this is the school as a whole through Ofsted outcomes, school staff through performance management policies, or pupils through marking of work, test results and the language we use, they all seem to have brought a message of, ‘but what if you tried harder? It’s not good enough yet.’
For school communities, staff and pupils this has had, and continues to have, a massive impact on self-esteem and mental health, leading us to think that we should always be heading for something bigger and better than before, never being content with what we have in that moment. It has also had an impact on our ability to be part of a team and support one another since this model focuses on doing better than everyone else and placing each of us in direct competition with our peers.
A lot of the behaviours we encounter in the classroom can be viewed as a direct result of this message. The child who refuses to start a task is actually really anxious that they won’t be able to complete it to a high enough standard. The child who refuses to write in their book is actually fed up with opening their book to see list of suggested improvements all over their work. The child screws up their work in the middle of a task is actually frustrated because their handwriting doesn’t look like the perfect cursive text printed on the board. The child who forgets their PE kit for the third week running because although they love being outside, they hate catching balls because they always drop it and are told to try harder.
We often don’t realise that we’ve said or written something that has this impact. In fact, sometimes we’re encouraged to give these messages through the expectations of marking or observation policies.
Sometimes we even say these things to ourselves, we talk negatively about a lesson observation or an incident in school. While it’s important to be reflective and learn from our experiences, it’s also important to celebrate the successes and achievements of each day.
Notice the language you use in the classroom and in your moments of reflection. Could it be tweaked to promote an attitude of growth mindset which focuses on our ability to learn and grow from all of our experiences? Could it help the both the children and ourselves to see that they can seek support to make improvements? Could it reflect the effort and investment made in a task rather than just looking at the final outcome?
Be kind. Always.